Last updated October 10, 2026 · ranked from 2,358 Google reviews · How we rank
The 10 best hotels in Saugatuck, MI all sit within the city, with Google ratings ranging from 4.8 to 5 stars. Luckystone Inn leads the list with a 5-star rating from 90 reviews, followed by Holiday Hill Resort at 4.9 stars from 192 reviews. Judson Heath Colonial Inn and Hidden Garden Cottages & Suites also hold 4.9-star ratings, while Wickwood Inn has 4.8 stars from 226 reviews. Porches On Mason, BaySide Inn and Twin Oaks Inn round out the final three spots. Across all ten entries, review counts range from 55 to 388, giving readers both ratings and review volume to compare.
Located at 938 W Center St in Douglas, the Victorian-style hotel has a 4.9 Google rating from 306 reviews. Guests praise the comfortable common rooms, spacious accommodations and helpful hosts, including their activity and restaurant recommendations. Bike rentals add another practical amenity, while one family of four specifically appreciated the accommodating cottage.
Complimentary breakfast
Heated pool
Bike rentals
“We had a wonderful stay at the Forest Inn. Eric and Tracy were incredible hosts from the moment we checked in until we said goodbye. The inn itself is wonderfully restored and decorated. The common rooms are comfortable with great ambian…”
The Hotel Saugatuck holds a 4.8 Google rating across 388 reviews, listed on Google as hotel.
Fireplaces and whirlpools
Complimentary dessert
Bikes noted by guests
“We had a relaxing stay at this quaint and tidy bed and breakfast! The staff was very accommodating and welcoming. The updated lobby was charming and thoughtfully appointed. We enjoyed the walkable trip into Saugatuck, just far enough awa…”
Holiday Hill Resort holds a 4.9 Google rating across 192 reviews, listed on Google as hotel.
River views
Treehouse accommodations
Clean modern suites
“Had a very nice stay. A great place to unwind, very nice view overlooking the river. Very nice and friendly people who will gladly answer any questions you have. For amenities, they thought of just about everything, from utensils, plates…”
Wickwood Inn holds a 4.8 Google rating across 226 reviews, listed on Google as hotel.
Complimentary homemade breakfast
Antiques and artwork
Warm, attentive staff
“Honestly I don't know how to summarize our experience into a review, but the Wickwood Inn is hands down one of the best places we have ever stayed at. Everything about the experience was top-notch. When you first arrive you immediately g…”
Luckystone Inn holds a 5.0 Google rating across 90 reviews, listed on Google as bed & breakfast.
Homemade breakfast scones
Spacious, spotless rooms
Easy town access
“What a great stay. I cannot say enough good things about the Luckystone Inn and Sarah the owner. The location is perfect the room was spotless and a timeless nod to the 1860’s. Everything is up to date and the morning breakfast was more…”
The Kirby Hotel & J Paul's Dining Room holds a 4.7 Google rating across 223 reviews, listed on Google as hotel.
“This place is a MUST STAY in Saugatuck Douglas area. Not only is the building and rooms gorgeous and surrounded with so much history, the staff are SO FRIENDLY and Chris will make you the best breakfast and dinner you’ll ever eat in your…”
Work at The Kirby Hotel & J Paul's Dining Room? Get your badge
Judson Heath Colonial Inn holds a 4.9 Google rating across 91 reviews, listed on Google as hotel.
Adults-only inn
Garden and terrace
Praised breakfasts
“We are repeat offenders and we would not stay anywhere else in Saugatuck now that we have found this amazing Bed and Breakfast. Everything about the Judson Heath Colonial Inn says, "Welcome". The proprietors, Stephen and Jen could not be…”
BaySide Inn holds a 4.8 Google rating across 95 reviews, listed on Google as bed & breakfast.
Waterfront room views
Complimentary snack table
Welcomes LGBTQ guests
“What a wonderful cozy inn! So welcoming and hospitable from beginning to end and really went over the top to be helpful and always provided surprising unexpected extras. Fabulous views from the waterfront rooms that are roomy with reall…”
Four individually styled rooms distinguish Hidden Garden Cottages & Suites at 247 Butler St in Saugatuck, MI. Its 4.9 Google rating from 65 reviews adds to those concrete strengths. The property also welcomes LGBTQ guests, making that welcome an explicit part of its listing.
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each hotel is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Saugatuck category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Which properties have the highest Google ratings in this guide?
Forest Inn of Saugatuck in Douglas, MI, and Holiday Hill Resort in Saugatuck, MI, both hold 4.9 ratings, with 306 and 192 reviews respectively. The Hotel Saugatuck and Wickwood Inn, both in Saugatuck, MI, follow at 4.8, with 388 and 226 reviews.
Which lodging options offer nightlife, dining or spa treatments?
The Dunes Resort LGBTQIA+, at 333 Blue Star Hwy in Douglas, MI, has a nightclub and live entertainment. The Kirby Hotel & J Paul's Dining Room, at 294 W Center St in Douglas, MI, combines lodging with a restaurant and wine bar; brunch and dinner reservations are recommended. Bella Vita Spa + Suites, at 119 Butler St in Saugatuck, MI, offers rooms, spa treatments and massages, with appointments required.
1
