Last updated October 6, 2026 · ranked from 140 Google reviews · How we rank
This list ranks 8 real estate agents in and around Saugatuck, MI, led by David Isljamovski, Real Estate Services, Coastal Living Advisors and Heather Conley - Century 21 Affiliated - Real Estate Professional. Together they have 140 Google reviews; David Isljamovski, Real Estate Services has the highest Google rating on the list at 5.0. Every place on the list is in Saugatuck, MI. Rankings weigh Google rating, review volume, how complete and current each listing is, and our own notes on each place.
A 5-star Google rating from 52 reviews and firsthand accounts of buying and selling support David Isljamovski’s No. 1 rank in Saugatuck, MI. One seller describes careful listing preparation and persistent pursuit of buyers for their Saugatuck, MI home. Other reviewers highlight clear communication, smooth transactions, and guidance from showings through closing. Based at 62 W Center St in Douglas, MI, the Century 21 Affiliated agent focuses on luxury properties and investment real estate, including waterfront condos.
Clear communication
Careful listing preparation
Luxury property focus
“I had the great honor of working with David when I needed to rent a house and when I was exploring options to buy in the area. He is a kind, thorough, and qualified real estate professional who makes the process seamless. He was able to …”
Work at David Isljamovski, Real Estate Services? Get your badge
Patient guidance and consistent communication earn Coastal Living Advisors the No. 3 spot among real estate agents serving Saugatuck, MI. Reviewers describe Kevin explaining each stage of a purchase, answering complicated questions, and listening closely to household needs. One buyer also notes support after the purchase. Based at 150 W Center St, Suite D, in Douglas, the business assists buyers, sellers, and investors across West Michigan. Its Google rating is 5 stars from 11 reviews, and listed hours include both Saturday and Sunday.
Step-by-step guidance
Post-purchase support
Weekend hours
“Kevin was outstanding to work with. He went above and beyond throughout the entire home-buying process, always making himself available and ensuring we understood every step. His professionalism, communication, and dedication made what c…”
Practical help with pricing and preparing homes for sale earns Heather Conley the No. 4 spot among real estate agents serving Saugatuck, MI. Reviewers describe her as responsive, patient and well-informed, with one crediting her guidance through both buying and selling and another praising her handling of listing, showings and property preparation. Based in Douglas with Century 21 Affiliated, she works with residential, investment and historical homes, including second homes and downsizing moves. Her Google listing holds a 5-star rating from 10 reviews.
Pricing guidance
Second-home expertise
Responsive communication
“Heather Conley’s knowledge of the Douglas and Saugatuck market is unmatched, and she guides her clients through every step of the process with confidence and ease. She is responsive, honest, and truly invested in helping her clients find…”
Work at Heather Conley - Century 21 Affiliated - Real Estate Professional? Get your badge
An interior design background and hands-on property experience earn Brennan Bohman Jaqua Realtors the No. 5 spot among real estate agents in Saugatuck, MI. Based at 202 W Center St in Douglas, Bohman holds a BS in Interior Design and began purchasing and flipping properties in 2009. Reviewers describe patient, responsive help with first-time purchases and out-of-state second homes, alongside knowledge of the West Michigan market. A 5-star Google rating from 13 reviews reinforces those accounts of informed, unpressured guidance.
Interior design background
Patient buyer guidance
West Michigan knowledge
“We have highly enjoyed working with Brennan on many projects! He knows the market and is very professional! We would definitely recommend him for any design projects or if you need a fabulous realtor!”
Clear communication and sustained client support earn Erica Shirey the No. 6 spot among real estate agents serving Saugatuck, MI. A Realtor and Associate Broker based at 62 W Center St in Douglas, she holds a 5-star Google rating from nine reviews. A local lender praises her punctuality and clear expectations, while one buyer describes roughly seven years of help searching for a retirement home. A first-time seller also credits her guidance with township approvals and coordination with an attorney.
Clear client communication
Long-term buyer support
First-time seller guidance
“Exceptional Realtor Experience!
As a local lender, I’ve had the privilege of working with Erica, and I can confidently say she sets the bar for professionalism. Her expertise in communication, punctuality, and setting clear expectations …”
Work at Erica Shirey, Realtor and Associate Broker - Saugatuck, Douglas, Holland, Fennville, and Surrounding Areas? Get your badge
Local market knowledge and professional referrals earn Beacon Sotheby's International Realty rank 7. One reviewer specifically praises Chad Van Horn’s knowledge of Saugatuck, MI and surrounding communities, while a Pennsylvania real estate advisor describes him as dependable and responsive when handling referred clients. The agency holds a 4.6 Google rating from 25 reviews. Based on Butler Street, its stated coverage extends along Lake Michigan to Grand Rapids and Kalamazoo. Online appointments and onsite services give clients two ways to connect.
Local market knowledge
Online appointments
Regional service area
“Chad is my go to agent in Michigan,
As a real estate advisor in Pennsylvania, I have complete confidence that Chad will work hard for my clients. He’s dependable, responsive and knowable.”
Work at Beacon Sotheby's International Realty? Get your badge
Almost 15 years of local experience and a focus on lakeshore property earn Kevin Schippa’s West Michigan Lakeshore Real Estate the No. 8 spot. Based in Douglas, Schippa serves buyers, sellers, and investors in Saugatuck, MI, with specialties spanning lakefront properties, residential listings, vacation homes, and investment real estate. He is affiliated with Better Homes & Gardens Real Estate Connections and holds a 5-star Google rating from four reviews. Posted hours extend to 9 p.m. Monday through Thursday, with weekend hours also listed.
Lakefront property focus
Vacation home expertise
Evening and weekend hours
Work at West Michigan Lakeshore Real Estate - Kevin Schippa-BHGRE Connections? Get your badge
Client accounts of quick sales and local knowledge earn Liz Engel - Century 21 Affiliated the No. 10 spot in Saugatuck, MI. One reviewer reports a sale within 24 hours, above asking price, and describes the process as seamless and professional. Another says the time from listing to completed sale was six weeks. Reviews also praise Engel’s knowledge of the market and local contacts. The business holds a 4.3 Google rating across 16 reviews, with wheelchair-accessible parking and an accessible entrance at its West Center Street office.
Reported quick sales
Local market knowledge
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
“Liz is the most knowledgeable Broker in all of Saugatuck. She cares for her clients deeply, uplifts and mentors the team, and brings a passion to real estate that I have not seen from any other professional. Even the most seasoned agen…”
Work at Liz Engel - Century 21 Affiliated? Get your badge
Map of every pick
Compare at a glance
Comparison of the best Real Estate Agents in Saugatuck, MI
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each real estate agent is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Saugatuck category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Real Estate Agents in Saugatuck, MI: common questions
Which real estate agents have the highest ratings in this guide?
David Isljamovski has 5.0 stars from 52 Google reviews, followed by Tammy Kerr with 5.0 from 32. Other agents and firms with 5.0 ratings include Brennan Bohman with 13 reviews, Coastal Living Advisors with 11, Heather Conley with 10, and Erica Shirey with 9.
Who handles waterfront and second-home purchases around Saugatuck, MI?
Tammy Kerr lists luxury, waterfront, and vacation properties along the Lake Michigan shoreline among her specialties. David Isljamovski focuses on luxury properties and investments, including waterfront condos. Heather Conley offers second-home expertise and downsizing guidance. Mill Pond Realty combines real estate sales with second-home vacation rental management.
Which agents offer evening or weekend hours?
David Isljamovski lists hours of 8 a.m.–10 p.m. daily, and Heather Conley lists 9 a.m.–9 p.m. daily. Coastal Living Advisors lists 9 a.m.–7 p.m. weekdays and 9 a.m.–5 p.m. weekends. Beacon Sotheby's International Realty in Saugatuck, MI lists Saturday hours of 10 a.m.–4 p.m., plus Tuesday–Friday hours of 10 a.m.–5 p.m.
Which offices offer online appointments and accessible entrances?
Beacon Sotheby's International Realty at 233 Butler St Box 217 in Saugatuck, MI and Heather Conley at 62 W Center St in Douglas both list online appointments, onsite services, wheelchair-accessible entrances, and wheelchair-accessible parking. David Isljamovski's office also lists a wheelchair-accessible restroom and seating.
Which agents have reviews describing help for first-time buyers or sellers?
A first-time buyer's review of Brennan Bohman describes feeling supported and informed, with patient answers and no pressure. At Jaqua, Realtors, a first-time buyer credits Erika Lacerda with guidance on inspections and negotiations. A first-time seller's review of Erica Shirey describes help with township approvals and coordination with an attorney.
1
